Best Places to Invest in New York in 2023

Experienced real estate investors have historically made quite a lucrative stream of income by investing in the New York City real estate market–in fact, according to the New York Post, renters are expected to make a minimum of $160k a year just in order to afford life in the Empire State. From single family homes to apartments and condos just off of Central Park, there are a lot of reasons to expect a strong rental market in NYC for years to come. But is this market approachable for first-time investors, and will 2023 be a good year to invest? Let’s explore these questions and more by looking at the best places to invest in New York in the coming years.

NYC Real Estate Investment: Where to Invest in New York City?

The heart of New York State, New York City, remains an epicenter of real estate activity. The city is a microcosm of diversity, with neighborhoods varying dramatically in terms of lifestyle, culture, and potential for investment return. Among these, a few neighborhoods deserve special attention:

Upper East Side, Manhattan, New York:

Nestled alongside the iconic Central Park, the Upper East Side holds its status as a timeless symbol of luxury and sophistication. This neighborhood’s historic brownstones, upscale boutiques, and proximity to renowned museums create an ambiance that consistently attracts high-end buyers and renters. With a reputation for stability and enduring value, properties in this area can offer solid returns over the long term.

sunset, manhattan, city, Manhattan neighborhoods, NYC neighborhoods, New York metropolitan area, rental properties, buy rental property, NYC rental market, New York real estate market

Staten Island:

Staten Island, often overshadowed by its more bustling counterparts, has been experiencing a renaissance. Improved transportation infrastructure, including the Staten Island Ferry and expanded bus routes, has made it a more accessible location. Its relative affordability compared to other boroughs, coupled with a quieter suburban feel and scenic waterfront views, has drawn both families and investors seeking a tranquil escape from the city’s hustle.

staten, nature, island

Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, New York:

Situated along the southwestern tip of Brooklyn, Bay Ridge is a hidden gem that combines urban convenience with a tight-knit community atmosphere. This neighborhood boasts a diverse blend of cultures, reflected in its range of eateries, shops, and local events. Its proximity to parks, waterfront access, and the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge’s recent renovations have made it increasingly attractive to young professionals and families.

brooklyn bridge, new york, bridge, best NYC neighborhoods for investing

Why Invest in NYC?

Investing in New York City offers a unique set of advantages. The city’s global reputation as a center for finance, culture, and innovation ensures a steady stream of residents and businesses seeking prime real estate. Limited space for new development, coupled with the city’s consistent population growth, means that real estate remains a scarce and valuable resource. This scarcity, in turn, drives both rental and property values higher, making NYC an attractive destination for investors seeking long-term appreciation and income potential.

The Impact of International Buyers in New York

New York City’s real estate market has a longstanding relationship with international buyers. The city’s allure as a melting pot of cultures and opportunities has drawn investors from all corners of the globe. This influx of international capital has historically driven the luxury segment of the market, leading to the creation of opulent residential skyscrapers and penthouses that redefine urban living. The interplay between international investment and the city’s cultural vibrancy continues to shape its architectural landscape and investor sentiment.

New York City’s Expanding Luxury Development

Luxury real estate development in New York City has never been more captivating. With innovation at the forefront, developers are crafting visionary residential spaces that meld cutting-edge architecture with opulent amenities. From sweeping penthouses with panoramic skyline views to eco-conscious high-rises that prioritize sustainability, the luxury real estate market in NYC remains a playground for architectural marvels that cater to the elite.

real estate, luxury, home, expensive market, high home price, expensive real estate markets, long term investment, residential buildings, luxury homes, luxury real estate

In essence, New York State, with its vibrant cities and neighborhoods, offers a dynamic spectrum of investment prospects. Whether focusing on the glamour of Manhattan’s Upper East Side, the quiet allure of Staten Island, or the diverse charm of Brooklyn’s Bay Ridge, investors have a multitude of opportunities to explore. By understanding the draw of international buyers, recognizing the potential for luxury development, and acknowledging the city’s innate appeal, investors can position themselves for success within the vibrant tapestry of New York’s real estate market in 2023 and beyond.

Is New York State a Good Real Estate Investment?

New York State offers a complex and diverse real estate landscape that can be an appealing investment opportunity for those who approach it with careful consideration. While historically known for its robust and often lucrative real estate market, several factors must be weighed before determining if New York State is a good real estate investment in the current context.

The Overall Cooling of the NYC Housing Market

In recent times, the New York City housing market has experienced a period of cooling. Factors such as changing demographic trends, remote work arrangements, and a general shift in housing preferences have influenced this slowdown. While the pace of price appreciation may have moderated compared to earlier years, it’s important to recognize that this cooling does not uniformly apply to all areas within New York State. Certain regions are still witnessing demand and growth, making it crucial for investors to carefully analyze micro-markets and neighborhoods.

Factors to Consider when Investing in Rental Properties in New York State

skyscraper, block of flats, building, NYC real estate investment, NYC real estate market, NYC real estate investment, rental property, buy rental property in New York City, strong rental market, NYC neighborhoods worth investing in, one bedroom apartments, two bedroom apartments, two bedroom apartment, investment opportunities NYC

Investing in rental properties in New York State requires a comprehensive understanding of both the local market and broader economic trends. Factors to consider include:

  1. Location: The old adage of “location, location, location” remains paramount. Proximity to amenities, transportation options, schools, and employment centers greatly influences rental demand and property values.
  2. Regulations: New York State has specific regulations and tenant protection laws that can significantly impact the landlord-tenant relationship and property management. Investors must be well-versed in these regulations to ensure compliance and mitigate legal risks.
  3. Economic Drivers: Consider the economic stability and growth potential of the area. Cities with diverse economies and job opportunities are more likely to sustain rental demand and property value appreciation.
  4. Market Trends: Research market trends, vacancy rates, and rental rates in the chosen area. An understanding of supply and demand dynamics will help gauge the potential profitability of a rental property.
  5. Property Condition: The state of the property itself is crucial. A well-maintained and modern property is more likely to attract tenants and command higher rents.

Best Places for an Investment Property in New York 2023

Investors looking to make sound real estate investments in New York State in 2023 have a range of potential opportunities to consider. Several key areas stand out for their unique attributes and growth potential, each offering its own blend of amenities, lifestyle, and investment prospects.

Albany: Capitalizing on Government Presence and Tech Growth

Albany, the state capital of New York, presents a compelling investment landscape. The city benefits from a stable government presence, which contributes to a consistent demand for rental properties. Moreover, Albany’s evolving tech industry provides an additional economic driver, attracting professionals seeking convenient housing options. The presence of reputable universities adds to the potential tenant pool, making Albany an appealing location for investors looking for steady rental income.

albany, capitol complex, albany new york, property in New York, local real estate agents in Albany, rental property in NYC, investment properties Albany

County Knolls: Suburban Tranquility with Urban Convenience

Situated within Clifton Park, County Knolls offers a suburban haven that seamlessly combines tranquility with convenience. This neighborhood’s proximity to Albany, just a short drive away, ensures access to major employment centers and cultural attractions. County Knolls’ reputation for safety and strong community ties further enhance its appeal for families and professionals seeking a peaceful yet well-connected lifestyle–and it is also the fastest growing city in New York (via Aceable). For investors, this blend of residential comfort and accessibility translates into a promising opportunity for rental properties.

Hampton Manor: Suburban Charm Close to Urban Amenities

Located in East Greenbush, Hampton Manor epitomizes the suburban dream while remaining within reach of Albany’s urban amenities. This residential area offers a serene environment characterized by tree-lined streets and well-maintained homes. Families are drawn to Hampton Manor’s family-friendly atmosphere and proximity to schools and parks. For investors, the area’s stable demand for family-oriented housing presents a favorable outlook for rental properties, especially given its balance between suburban living and urban accessibility.

Buffalo: Riding the Wave of Revitalization

Buffalo’s renaissance is capturing the attention of investors seeking growth and potential returns. The city’s diverse economy, bolstered by educational institutions and cultural attractions, positions it as a rising star in New York State. Buffalo’s ongoing efforts to revitalize its downtown and waterfront areas have the potential to create exciting investment opportunities. As more professionals and families are drawn to the city’s expanding job market and quality of life, the demand for rental properties is expected to follow suit.

East Glenville: Suburban Living with Proximity to Urban Centers

Nestled in Schenectady County, East Glenville offers a blend of suburban living and accessibility to urban centers. Its location, not far from both Albany and Schenectady, ensures a steady stream of potential tenants seeking the balance between a peaceful lifestyle and easy access to employment opportunities. With recreational activities, parks, and amenities nearby, East Glenville’s appeal extends to families and individuals looking for a comfortable yet well-connected living environment.

Is NYC Real Estate A Good Investment?

Investing in New York City (NYC) real estate is a topic of great interest, but it’s important to consider various factors that can significantly influence the viability of such an investment. Let’s delve into these factors to better understand the potential benefits and challenges of investing in NYC real estate:

Property Tax Rates and Regulations:

Property taxes in NYC can be substantial and should be a critical consideration for potential investors. High property taxes can impact the overall return on investment, affecting both rental income and potential resale value. Familiarizing oneself with the local property tax rates and regulations is crucial for accurate financial planning.

Property Type:

The type of property you invest in matters greatly. NYC offers a diverse range of properties, including condos, co-ops, townhouses, and single-family homes. Each property type comes with its own set of considerations, such as maintenance costs, ownership structure, and potential rental demand.

Why It’s Not Just About Rental Yield:

While rental yield (the income generated from rent relative to the property’s value) is an important metric, it’s not the sole indicator of a good investment in NYC. The city’s real estate market is also influenced by appreciation potential, which has historically been a significant driver of returns. Investing in NYC real estate can provide long-term value appreciation, even if rental yields appear lower compared to other markets.

Tax Advantages:

Investors can benefit from certain tax advantages when investing in NYC real estate. Tax deductions related to property expenses, mortgage interest, and depreciation can help mitigate the tax burden associated with rental income. However, tax laws can be complex, and seeking advice from financial experts is recommended before leaping into a real estate commitment.

When in doubt, begin by looking at local tax laws in comparison to the national average. For more on local area, check out this resource from the NYC Department of Finance. For reference, New York currently experiences a property tax rate of 1.72%, which is above the national average and well above other states like Colorado at 0.51% (from RocketHomes).

Employment Rates and Job Growth:

The health of the job market and employment rates directly impact rental demand. NYC’s diverse economy and status as a global business hub ensure a relatively stable job market, contributing to a consistent stream of potential tenants. However, economic downturns can affect job stability and, consequently, rental demand.

Mansion Tax in New York City: To Avoid or Not?

The Mansion Tax is a one-time tax on residential properties in NYC that are sold for $1 million or more. The tax rate varies based on the sale price and can add a significant cost to luxury property transactions. Investors should evaluate the potential impact of the Mansion Tax on their investment strategy and financial goals.

Is Investing in New York Real Estate Overpriced?

The question of whether investing in NYC real estate is overpriced is complex and subjective. While property prices in NYC can be high compared to other markets, they are often reflective of the city’s global prominence, demand, and limited space for development. Additionally, the potential for value appreciation over time can offset the initial high purchase price.

usa, manhattan, real estate investors NYC, best place for an investment property, rental property NYC, affordable housing NYC, best NYC neighborhoods for investing

Investment Property Mortgage with No Personal Income Verification – DSCR Loan

A Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) loan is a financing option that has gained attention among real estate investors. This type of loan focuses on the income-generating potential of the property itself rather than the borrower’s personal income. It considers the property’s rental income and expenses to determine whether it generates sufficient cash flow to cover the mortgage payments. DSCR loans can be particularly attractive for investors with multiple properties or those who rely on rental income for repayment.

Emerging Areas in NY for Real Estate Investments: Exploring Opportunities

New York State is a dynamic real estate market with emerging areas that hold promise for savvy investors. Some regions experiencing revitalization and growth include:

  • The Bronx: Several neighborhoods in The Bronx are undergoing transformation, attracting both residential and commercial investors. Areas like Mott Haven and Port Morris have seen a surge in development, presenting opportunities for those looking to invest in up-and-coming locations.
  • Long Island City: Situated just across the East River from Manhattan, Long Island City has seen a boom in luxury condominiums and rental properties. Its proximity to the city and stunning skyline views have made it a hotspot for real estate investment.
  • Brooklyn Neighborhoods: While certain neighborhoods in Brooklyn have already established themselves, areas like Bushwick and East New York continue to evolve. Investors seeking growth potential may find opportunities in these expanding neighborhoods.

How Much Do Real Estate Investors Make in NYC?

The earnings of real estate investors in NYC vary widely depending on factors such as property type, location, market conditions, and investment strategy. Some investors focus on rental income as their primary source of earnings, while others prioritize property appreciation. Rental income in NYC can range from modest to substantial, with luxury properties commanding higher rents. Additionally, value appreciation over time can lead to significant returns, particularly in prime locations.

Do I Need a Local Real Estate Agent to Make a Good Investment in NY?

Having a local real estate agent can offer significant advantages when investing in New York–though they are not always necessary, especially with share-by-share real estate investing. Local agents possess in-depth knowledge of the market, neighborhoods, pricing trends, and emerging areas. They can provide valuable insights, identify potentially lucrative investment opportunities, and guide you through the intricacies of property transactions. However, if you already have a deep understanding of your investment goals, investing in New York can be as easy as a simple click!

New York City Real Estate and the Greater NY Area: Investing with Ark7

Clearly, real estate investors interested in New York must weigh many factors when it comes to buying a property in the Empire State. From local property taxes, median listing home price, and average rent to location, school districts, and tourism attractions and economy, buying New York homes, apartments, or commercial properties is nothing to be taken lightly. With the average rent sometimes costing as much as $88 per square foot in 2023 (from RentHop), this market can be just as dangerous as it can be deadly. This is why investing in New York City is generally best left to experienced investors looking to expand their portfolio–but fortunately, the rest of the state offers ample opportunities for smart first-time investments.

Here are some other articles that might be helpful –

Scroll to Top